Files
asterisk/tests/test_codec_translations.c
Sebastian Jennen ef7dc45b77 tests: add tests/test_codec_translations.c
This tests checks [slin -> codec -> slin] and then compares slin in vs out
regarding signal noise ratio and delay.

Near-lossless codecs (ulaw, alaw) are checked with a maximum per-sample
error bound.  Lossy codecs are checked with a per-codec SNR threshold.
Cross-correlation alignment compensates for algorithmic delay in codecs
like speex and opus.

Covered codecs: ulaw, alaw, adpcm, g726, g726aal2, gsm, speex,
speex16, speex32, ilbc, codec2, lpc10, g722, opus.

Resolves: #1812
2026-05-22 16:16:43 +00:00

553 lines
17 KiB
C

/*
* Asterisk -- An open source telephony toolkit.
*
* Copyright (C) 2026, Asterisk Community
*
* See http://www.asterisk.org for more information about
* the Asterisk project. Please do not directly contact
* any of the maintainers of this project for assistance;
* the project provides a web site, mailing lists and IRC
* channels for your use.
*
* This program is free software, distributed under the terms of
* the GNU General Public License Version 2. See the LICENSE file
* at the top of the source tree.
*/
/*!
* \file
* \brief Codec Translation Roundtrip Tests
*
* \author Sebastian Jennen <sebastian.t.jennen@gmail.com>
*
* Tests that encoding sample frames through a codec and decoding them
* back to slin produces output that is (almost) identical to
* the original input. This verifies that each codec translator pair
* (slin -> codec -> slin) does not corrupt or destroy the audio signal.
*
* For near-lossless codecs (alaw, ulaw) the tolerance is very tight.
* For lossy codecs (adpcm, g726, gsm, g722, speex, ilbc, opus, g729, etc.)
* a Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) threshold is used since some degradation
* is inherent to the compression algorithm. Wideband codecs are tested
* with a matching slin16/slin32/slin48 signal at the codec's native
* sample rate.
*/
/*** MODULEINFO
<depend>TEST_FRAMEWORK</depend>
<support_level>extended</support_level>
***/
#include "asterisk.h"
#include <math.h>
#include "asterisk/module.h"
#include "asterisk/test.h"
#include "asterisk/translate.h"
#include "asterisk/format.h"
#include "asterisk/format_cap.h"
#include "asterisk/format_cache.h"
#include "asterisk/codec.h"
#include "asterisk/frame.h"
#include "asterisk/slin.h"
#include "asterisk/logger.h"
#include "asterisk/utils.h"
/*! Duration of the test signal in seconds */
#define TEST_DURATION_SECS 2
/*! Chunk duration in milliseconds to feed chunks to the coders */
#define CHUNK_MS 20
/*! Minimum acceptable SNR in dB for lossy codecs.
* Most telephony codecs at 8 kHz should exceed ~20 dB */
#define MIN_SNR_LOSSY_DB 15.0
/*! Maximum per-sample absolute error for near-lossless codecs (ulaw/alaw).
* μ-law/A-law quantisation can reach a max error of 256. */
#define MAX_SAMPLE_ERR_LOSSLESS 256
/*! Minimum fraction of input samples that must survive the roundtrip.
* Codec lookahead + trailing partial frame may consume some samples;
* require at least 90 % to call the test valid. */
#define MIN_DECODED_RATIO 0.90
/*!
* \brief Generate a synthetic speech-like test signal in linear sample.
*
* a mix of a 200 Hz fundamental and an 800 Hz harmonic with a slow 4 Hz
* amplitude-modulation envelope, loosely inspired by ITU-T P.50 artificial
* voice.
*
* \param[out] buf Buffer to fill (must hold at least \a samples int16 values)
* \param[in] samples Number of samples to generate
* \param[in] sample_rate Sampling rate in Hz (used to scale time correctly)
*/
static void generate_speech_signal(int16_t *buf, int samples, int sample_rate)
{
int i;
for (i = 0; i < samples; i++) {
double t = (double)i / sample_rate;
double sig = 0.6 * sin(2.0 * M_PI * 200.0 * t)
+ 0.4 * sin(2.0 * M_PI * 800.0 * t);
/* Slow AM at 4 Hz to simulate syllable rhythm */
sig *= 0.5 * (1.0 + sin(2.0 * M_PI * 4.0 * t));
buf[i] = (int16_t)(sig * 16000.0);
}
}
/*!
* \brief Compute Signal-to-Noise Ratio between original and roundtripped signal.
*
* \param[in] orig Original sample buffer
* \param[in] roundtrip Decoded (roundtripped) sample buffer
* \param[in] samples Number of samples
*
* \return SNR in dB
*/
static double compute_snr(const int16_t *orig, const int16_t *roundtrip, int samples)
{
double signal_power = 0.0;
double noise_power = 0.0;
int i;
for (i = 0; i < samples; i++) {
double s = (double)orig[i];
double n = (double)(orig[i] - roundtrip[i]);
signal_power += s * s;
noise_power += n * n;
}
if (signal_power < 1.0) {
return -100.0; /* degenerate signal */
}
if (noise_power < 1.0) {
return 999.0; /* essentially perfect */
}
return 10.0 * log10(signal_power / noise_power);
}
/*!
* \brief Compute SNR after aligning the decoded signal via cross-correlation.
*
* Some codecs (e.g. speex, opus) introduce an algorithmic lookahead delay:
* the decoded signal is time-shifted by a fixed number of samples relative to
* the original. Computing SNR without compensating for this shift yields a
* near-zero result even when the codec works perfectly.
*
* This function searches delays d = 0..max_delay, finds the integer shift
* that maximises the cross-correlation sum orig[i]·decoded[i+d], then returns
* the SNR computed at that optimal alignment.
*
* \param[in] orig Original sample buffer (must hold at least \a samples values)
* \param[in] decoded Decoded sample buffer (must hold at least \a samples values)
* \param[in] samples Number of samples available in each buffer
* \param[in] max_delay Search range: delays 0..max_delay are tested
* \param[out] delay_out Receives the best-fit delay found; may be NULL
*
* \return SNR in dB at the best-fit alignment, or the unaligned SNR when
* \a samples <= \a max_delay
*/
static double compute_snr_aligned(const int16_t *orig, const int16_t *decoded,
int samples, int max_delay, int *delay_out)
{
double best_corr = -1e300;
int best_delay = 0;
int d;
if (delay_out) {
*delay_out = 0;
}
/* Need enough samples for a meaningful search */
if (samples <= max_delay || max_delay <= 0) {
return compute_snr(orig, decoded, samples);
}
for (d = 0; d <= max_delay; d++) {
int n = samples - d;
double corr = 0.0;
int i;
for (i = 0; i < n; i++) {
corr += (double)orig[i] * (double)decoded[i + d];
}
if (corr > best_corr) {
best_corr = corr;
best_delay = d;
}
}
if (delay_out) {
*delay_out = best_delay;
}
/* Compute SNR at the best alignment */
return compute_snr(orig, decoded + best_delay, samples - best_delay);
}
/*!
* \brief Compute maximum absolute per-sample error.
*/
static int compute_max_error(const int16_t *orig, const int16_t *roundtrip, int samples)
{
int max_err = 0;
int i;
for (i = 0; i < samples; i++) {
int err = abs((int)orig[i] - (int)roundtrip[i]);
if (err > max_err) {
max_err = err;
}
}
return max_err;
}
/*!
* \brief Attempt a roundtrip encode/decode for one codec format.
*
* Feeds the original slin signal through the encoder and decoder in 20 ms
* chunks (matching the universal VoIP frame duration), accumulates the
* decoded output, and compares the full result against the original.
* This naturally respects every codec's internal buffer sizes and frame
* granularity without needing per-codec sample-count overrides.
*
* \param[in] test Test framework handle (for status messages)
* \param[in] slin_fmt The slin format appropriate for the codec's sample rate
* \param[in] target_fmt The codec format to test
* \param[in] orig_buf Original slin sample buffer
* \param[in] total_samples Number of samples in orig_buf
* \param[in] sample_rate Sample rate in Hz
* \param[in] is_lossy If non-zero, use SNR-based comparison; otherwise use max-error
* \param[in] min_snr_db Minimum acceptable SNR for lossy check (ignored when !is_lossy)
*
* \retval AST_TEST_PASS on success
* \retval AST_TEST_FAIL on failure
*/
static enum ast_test_result_state check_codec(
struct ast_test *test,
struct ast_format *slin_fmt,
struct ast_format *target_fmt,
const int16_t *orig_buf,
int total_samples,
int sample_rate,
int is_lossy,
double min_snr_db)
{
struct ast_trans_pvt *encode_path = NULL;
struct ast_trans_pvt *decode_path = NULL;
int16_t *decoded_buf = NULL;
int total_decoded = 0;
int chunk_samples = sample_rate * CHUNK_MS / 1000;
int buf_capacity;
int offset;
enum ast_test_result_state result = AST_TEST_FAIL;
const char *codec_name;
codec_name = ast_format_get_name(target_fmt);
/* --- Build encoder path: slin -> codec --- */
encode_path = ast_translator_build_path(target_fmt, slin_fmt);
if (!encode_path) {
ast_test_status_update(test,
"Skipping %s: no translation path from slin to %s\n",
codec_name, codec_name);
return AST_TEST_PASS;
}
/* --- Build decoder path: codec -> slin --- */
decode_path = ast_translator_build_path(slin_fmt, target_fmt);
if (!decode_path) {
ast_test_status_update(test,
"FAIL %s: found encoder but no decoder path back to slin\n",
codec_name);
goto cleanup;
}
/* Allocate output buffer with some headroom for codec expansion */
buf_capacity = total_samples + chunk_samples;
decoded_buf = ast_calloc(buf_capacity, sizeof(int16_t));
if (!decoded_buf) {
goto cleanup;
}
/* --- Feed audio in CHUNK_MS chunks through encode -> decode --- */
for (offset = 0; offset < total_samples; offset += chunk_samples) {
struct ast_frame input_frame;
struct ast_frame *encoded;
struct ast_frame *decoded;
struct ast_frame *cur;
int feed = total_samples - offset;
if (feed > chunk_samples) {
feed = chunk_samples;
}
memset(&input_frame, 0, sizeof(input_frame));
input_frame.frametype = AST_FRAME_VOICE;
input_frame.subclass.format = slin_fmt;
input_frame.datalen = feed * sizeof(int16_t);
input_frame.samples = feed;
input_frame.data.ptr = (void *)(orig_buf + offset);
input_frame.mallocd = 0;
input_frame.src = "test_codec_translations";
/* Encode: slin -> codec. NULL means the encoder is buffering. */
encoded = ast_translate(encode_path, &input_frame, 0);
if (!encoded) {
continue;
}
/* Decode: codec -> slin. ast_translate follows the frame linked
* list internally, so passing the head feeds all encoded frames. */
decoded = ast_translate(decode_path, encoded, 0);
if (!decoded) {
continue;
}
/* Copy decoded samples into our accumulation buffer.
* Walk the linked list in case frameout produced multiple frames. */
for (cur = decoded; cur; cur = AST_LIST_NEXT(cur, frame_list)) {
int copy;
if (cur->frametype != AST_FRAME_VOICE || !cur->data.ptr
|| cur->samples <= 0) {
continue;
}
copy = cur->samples;
if (total_decoded + copy > buf_capacity) {
copy = buf_capacity - total_decoded;
}
memcpy(decoded_buf + total_decoded, cur->data.ptr,
copy * sizeof(int16_t));
total_decoded += copy;
}
}
/* --- Verify we got enough decoded audio --- */
if (total_decoded < (int)(total_samples * MIN_DECODED_RATIO)) {
ast_test_status_update(test,
"FAIL %s: decoded only %d of %d samples (%.0f%%)\n",
codec_name, total_decoded, total_samples,
100.0 * total_decoded / total_samples);
goto cleanup;
}
/* --- Compare original vs decoded --- */
{
int cmp_samples = total_decoded < total_samples
? total_decoded : total_samples;
if (is_lossy) {
int max_delay = sample_rate * 20 / 1000; /* 20 ms search */
int delay = 0;
double snr = compute_snr_aligned(orig_buf, decoded_buf,
cmp_samples, max_delay, &delay);
ast_test_status_update(test,
" %s (lossy): SNR = %.1f dB (threshold %.1f dB)"
" [%d/%d samples, delay=%d/%.1fms]\n",
codec_name, snr, min_snr_db,
cmp_samples, total_samples,
delay, 1000.0 * delay / sample_rate);
if (snr < min_snr_db) {
ast_test_status_update(test,
"FAIL %s: SNR %.1f dB is below minimum %.1f dB\n",
codec_name, snr, min_snr_db);
goto cleanup;
}
} else {
int max_err = compute_max_error(orig_buf, decoded_buf, cmp_samples);
double snr = compute_snr(orig_buf, decoded_buf, cmp_samples);
ast_test_status_update(test,
" %s (lossless): max_err = %d (limit %d),"
" SNR = %.1f dB [%d/%d samples]\n",
codec_name, max_err, MAX_SAMPLE_ERR_LOSSLESS, snr,
cmp_samples, total_samples);
if (max_err > MAX_SAMPLE_ERR_LOSSLESS) {
ast_test_status_update(test,
"FAIL %s: max sample error %d exceeds limit %d\n",
codec_name, max_err, MAX_SAMPLE_ERR_LOSSLESS);
goto cleanup;
}
}
}
result = AST_TEST_PASS;
cleanup:
ast_free(decoded_buf);
if (encode_path) {
ast_translator_free_path(encode_path);
}
if (decode_path) {
ast_translator_free_path(decode_path);
}
return result;
}
/*!
* \brief Codec roundtrip entry: table of codecs to test.
*/
struct codec_test_entry {
const char *format_name; /*!< Name used in ast_format_cache_get() */
int is_lossy; /*!< 1 = lossy (use SNR check), 0 = near-lossless (use max err) */
double min_snr_db; /*!< Per-codec SNR floor; 0.0 = use MIN_SNR_LOSSY_DB default */
int sample_rate; /*!< Native slin rate: 8000/16000/32000/48000; 0 = default 8000 */
};
/*! Table of codecs to roundtrip-test.*/
static const struct codec_test_entry codec_table[] = {
/* Near-lossless narrowband (8 kHz) — verified with max per-sample error */
{ "ulaw", 0 },
{ "alaw", 0 },
/* Lossy narrowband (8 kHz) — verified with SNR threshold */
{ "adpcm", 1 }, /* ADPCM: ~20 dB SNR, lossy by design */
{ "g726", 1 }, /* G.726 ADPCM: ~28 dB SNR, lossy by design */
{ "g726aal2", 1 }, /* G.726 AAL2 ADPCM: same as g726 */
{ "gsm", 1 },
{ "speex", 1, 7.0 }, /* speex is quite lossy */
{ "ilbc", 1, 7.0 }, /* 30 ms frames: coarser quantisation lowers SNR floor */
{ "codec2", 1, -2.0 }, /* vocoder: snr is really low, smoke-test only */
{ "lpc10", 1, -2.0 }, /* vocoder: snr is really low, smoke-test only */
/* { "g729", 1 }, UNTESTED yet */
/* { "silk8", 1 }, UNTESTED yet */
/* { "silk12", 1 }, UNTESTED yet */
/* { "silk16", 1 }, UNTESTED yet */
/* { "silk24", 1 }, UNTESTED yet */
/* Wideband (16 kHz) — tested with slin16 signal. */
{ "g722", 1, 0.0, 16000 },
{ "speex16", 1, 5.0, 16000 },
/* Ultra-wideband (32 kHz) — tested with slin32 signal */
{ "speex32", 1, 5.0, 32000 },
/* Opus native rate is 48 kHz */
{ "opus", 1, 8.0, 48000 },
};
AST_TEST_DEFINE(codec_translate_roundtrip)
{
int i;
int tested = 0;
int failed = 0;
enum ast_test_result_state overall = AST_TEST_PASS;
switch (cmd) {
case TEST_INIT:
info->name = "codec_translations";
info->category = "/main/codec/";
info->summary = "Roundtrip encode/decode test and quality check for various codecs referenced in this test and present in the installation";
info->description =
"Generates a synthetic speech-like signal (200 Hz +\n"
"800 Hz with 4 Hz AM envelope) at the codec's native sample\n"
"rate, feeds it through the codec and back,\n"
"then verifies the output quality over the full duration.\n"
"For near-lossless codecs (ulaw, alaw) it checks that the\n"
"maximum per-sample error is within a tight bound.\n"
"For lossy codecs it checks that the SNR exceeds a per-codec\n"
"minimum threshold. Vocoders use a near-zero threshold\n"
"(smoke test).";
return AST_TEST_NOT_RUN;
case TEST_EXECUTE:
break;
}
ast_test_status_update(test,
"Starting codec roundtrip tests (%d codecs, %d seconds of audio)\n",
(int)ARRAY_LEN(codec_table), TEST_DURATION_SECS);
for (i = 0; i < (int)ARRAY_LEN(codec_table); i++) {
struct ast_format *slin_fmt;
struct ast_format *target_fmt;
int16_t *orig_buf;
enum ast_test_result_state res;
int rate = codec_table[i].sample_rate > 0
? codec_table[i].sample_rate : 8000;
int total_samples = rate * TEST_DURATION_SECS;
/* Select the slin format for this codec's native rate */
switch (rate) {
case 16000:
slin_fmt = ast_format_slin16;
break;
case 32000:
slin_fmt = ast_format_slin32;
break;
case 48000:
slin_fmt = ast_format_slin48;
break;
default:
slin_fmt = ast_format_slin;
break;
}
target_fmt = ast_format_cache_get(codec_table[i].format_name);
if (!target_fmt
|| ast_translate_path_steps(target_fmt, slin_fmt) == -1) {
ast_test_status_update(test,
" %s: no translation path available, skipping\n",
codec_table[i].format_name);
ao2_cleanup(target_fmt);
continue;
}
orig_buf = ast_malloc(total_samples * sizeof(int16_t));
if (!orig_buf) {
ao2_ref(target_fmt, -1);
overall = AST_TEST_FAIL;
break;
}
generate_speech_signal(orig_buf, total_samples, rate);
res = check_codec(
test, slin_fmt, target_fmt, orig_buf,
total_samples, rate,
codec_table[i].is_lossy,
codec_table[i].min_snr_db != 0.0
? codec_table[i].min_snr_db : MIN_SNR_LOSSY_DB);
ast_free(orig_buf);
ao2_ref(target_fmt, -1);
tested++;
if (res == AST_TEST_FAIL) {
failed++;
overall = AST_TEST_FAIL;
}
}
ast_test_status_update(test,
"\nCodec roundtrip summary: %d tested, %d passed, %d failed\n",
tested, tested - failed, failed);
if (tested == 0) {
ast_test_status_update(test,
"WARNING: No codecs were available to test. "
"Ensure codec modules are loaded.\n");
}
return overall;
}
static int unload_module(void)
{
AST_TEST_UNREGISTER(codec_translate_roundtrip);
return 0;
}
static int load_module(void)
{
AST_TEST_REGISTER(codec_translate_roundtrip);
return AST_MODULE_LOAD_SUCCESS;
}
AST_MODULE_INFO_STANDARD_EXTENDED(ASTERISK_GPL_KEY, "Codec Translation Roundtrip Tests");